An Empire of Ashes
Written: Jul 31 '03 (Updated Aug 17 '08)
|
Product Rating:
|
|
|
Pros: Great characterization, wonderful use of characters from the series
Cons: Some writing let-downs and illogical happenings, one-note villains
The Bottom Line: The bottom line is a usurper who should be flogged and killed.
|
|
|
| hist's Full Review: The Left Hand of Destiny Book Books |
The Left Hand of Destiny: Book 1, by J.G. Hertzler & Jeffrey Lang, is the first book of a two-part story about the new Klingon Chancellor, Martok. If you have seen Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, you have seen Martok as a general. At the end of the series, Martok was raised to Chancellor of the Klingon Empire. This is the story of his journey home from Deep Space Nine, and what awaits him when he gets there. It is very well-written for a first-time author and the book packs quite a punch for any Trek fan.
The Story
Chancellor Martok is coming home. Having served the Empire for years as a military officer, he is now a politician, and the taste is not good in his mouth. However, his duty to his people overrides all personal feeling. The Klingon Empire is in shambles, and Martok must save it from itself. He is coming home to assume his post, when treachery strikes. A usurper to the Imperial Throne has come out of the darkness, a mysterious figure with links to Martok’s past. Is this a power-grab or merely revenge? Whatever it is, the usurper will stop at nothing to achieve his goals, committing many unspeakable acts. As Martok goes deeper and deeper into the conspiracy, he finds something even more troubling behind it all. Something that is attempting to reach out and destroy him, creating a new Klingon Empire as well.
What Did I Think?
J.G. Hertzler played Martok on the television show, so you can tell that this story is near to his heart. Usually when an actor decides to write a book, it doesn’t turn out to be very good. The success rate is a little better when the book is about the character they’ve played. Trek has a good track record in this, though. Andy Robinson wrote the wonderful Stitch in Time and Armin Shimmerman co-wrote The 34th Rule about his Ferengi character. Both of those books were wonderful.
Hertzler adds another one to the pile. If you’re a Trek fan and an admirer of Martok, this is definitely the book for you. It is well-written (with a couple of missteps detailed below) and very interesting. It brings back many familiar characters from the television show, but none of them feel forced. They all serve a purpose and are appropriate for this story. Not only that, but Hertzler captures their characterization really well. I don’t know if that’s Lang’s influence or if Hertzler picked it all up while being on the show, but there are no out of character moments in this book. Worf and his son Alexander are the most recognizable of the bunch, but characters from Martok’s family also show up and are perfectly captured from the one episode that featured them. Emperor Kahless is almost a brand new character, since he didn’t really get a lot of characterization in the one episode that featured him. In addition to that, he has changed a great deal since that time. He adds a bit of colour to everything.
The original characters are also interesting, though the villains are a bit one-note and moustache-twirling to suit my taste. There are very few scenes from their viewpoint, but it still felt a little off. The other main original character, Pharh the Ferengi, is priceless though. He provides a lot of the comic relief in the novel, but he’s also an intelligent character. He’s not like most Ferengi. While commerce and money are still everything to him, he’s not as mercenary as most of the members of his race. Instead, he’s a three dimensional character who is a joy to read about. The interaction between Martok and him not only adds to Martok’s character but also makes the story more entertaining as a whole.
Of course, the tour de force is Martok himself. Hertzler shows that he truly understood the character he played on the show. Martok is deep, brooding, and hesitant to assume this role that has been thrust upon him. He loves his people and the Empire, but he does not see himself as the savior that they need. He feels he is simply a man, not a symbol. He would dearly love to put down the mantle of responsibility that he has been given when the usurper shows up, but he knows he can’t. I could hear Hertzler’s characteristic growl whenever Martok spoke in the book, and that’s a tribute to the authors. The good thing about these Deep Space Nine books is that the characters can grow and change. We learn a lot about Martok in this book, even as he learns a lot about himself and his limits. We get a history for him that he never had on the show. I think it produced an even more well-rounded character (though he was wonderful in the show as well). Kudos to Hertzler for this one.
There are a couple of missteps that bring the level of the book down a little bit. These missteps are something any first-time author could do, though you would hope the editors would catch it. First, in a couple of scenes, characters appear (or at least their thoughts do) even when they aren’t actually in the scene. For example, a scene is told from Alexander’s point of view, and there is one instance in that scene where we also get Martok’s impressions of what’s going on. He is watching the same thing from elsewhere, so we really shouldn’t be getting his thoughts at this time. The fact that his name only appears once in the scene makes me think that the authors just lost track for a moment. Secondly, some of the action is just impossible as it’s described. In one scene, one of the characters does a back-flip through somebody’s legs. I had to do a double-take for a moment. These and other small problems plague the book and bring it down from a 5-star effort. All of them could have been fixed with a quick re-reading, and I would have thought Lang would know better.
Still, this is a wonderful book from a new writer. Book 2 sounds like a roller-coaster ride as well. I hope we get some more Martok stories from Hertzler in the future. If you’re a DS9 fan, you owe it to yourself to check this one out.
Other Deep Space Nine continuation books:
Avatar
Section 31: Abyss
Demons of Air & Darkness
Mission Gamma: Twilight
Mission Gamma: This Gray Spirit
Mission Gamma: Cathedral
Mission Gamma: Lesser Evil
Rising Son
Unity
Worlds of Deep Space Nine: Cardassia & Andor
Worlds of Deep Space Nine: Bajor & Trill
Worlds of Deep Space Nine: Dominion & Ferenginar
Warpath
Fearful Symmetry
A Stitch in Time
Left Hand of Destiny: Book 1
Left Hand of Destiny: Book 2
Recommended:
Yes
|
|
|
|
Epinions.com ID:
hist
|
 in Books |
|
Member: David Roy
Location: Vancouver, BC
Reviews written: 723
Trusted by: 218 members
About Me:Thinking of taking Greyhound? Be careful:
|
|
|
- Add to My Yahoo!: 
- Add to Google Homepage: 
© 1999-2009 Shopping.com, Inc.